A Carolina Hurricanes blog with occasional news about the rest of the NHL.

Saturday, August 23, 2008

Tanabe situation gets murkier

On Friday, Chip Alexander reported that David Tanabe is still suffering from concussion-like or post-concussion symptoms. It has now been seven months since his mysterious injury and two since the Canes attempted to buy out the remaining year on his contract.

I have openly questioned the validity of his situation, and I have been unimpressed with the "details" that have emerged. This doesn't accord with my outspoken support for taking concussions very seriously, but I'm just not making heads or tails of this situation.

The occurrence of the injury itself can't be pinpointed, but we know that he was taken out of the December 18 game against the Leafs and never returned during the 2007-08 season. Had he been injured previously and some mild collision put him over the edge? Perhaps. That's the consensus. His refusal to go to team meetings and exit interviews has been well documented. His decision to clean out his own locker has been well documented. What has not been documented has been his medical status. The only details we have been afforded have been shady at best. Usually, injury status updates are more frequent and more detailed, but we went months without hearing a single word. Even now, we get some very unspecific news that Tanabe is "unfit to play".

Unfortunately, we haven't been given any details. When someone has an issue with their foot, we usually get lots of details, such as with Ryan Whitney:
Pittsburgh Penguins defenceman Ryan Whitney will be out three to five months following surgery to correct a chronic problem with his left foot... Dr. Robert Anderson operated Friday in Charlotte, N.C. The newspaper described the surgery as an osteotomy, defined as a procedure to shorten, lengthen or realign a bone or bones.
(via Canadian Press)
When Matt Cullen was out with a concussion, we were given nearly daily updates with specific details about what kinds of specialists he was seeing and what his specific problems were. Take this one for example, from the N&O on Feb 2:
In addition to Mike Peters, the team's eye doctor, Cullen is also working with concussion expert Kevin Guskiewicz at the University of North Carolina and Cary neuro-optometrist Susan Durham.


So why now do we get the vaguest of details? All we know is that Tanabe went to an anonymous doctor at an anonymous clinic in Buffalo who gave the very broad prognosis: "not a clean bill of health".

Anyway, Jim Rutherford has announced that he expects for Tanabe to report to camp and be monitored by official team doctors. This might help shed some light on things. I know concussions are hard things to work with because of the complexity of symptoms and the fact that they aren't as easy to diagnose and monitor as, say, a broken bone. Still, it's very frustrating to not know anything about the status.

17 comments:

Anonymous said...

I just posted on LSB before reading your comments. I just could not agree more with you. Something is terribly wrong here and it does not speak well for Tanabe's camp.

For a while, he was not even listed on the IR list.

Everything has been so mysterious makes me think that there is something really bad happening within the org and that it is not necessarily "neurological".

singnals3 said...

I just could not agree more with you. Something is terribly wrong here and it does not speak well for Tanabe's camp.

Get More Details

Anonymous said...

Hi! Kenneth Bryant . payday loans

Anonymous said...

cash advance toronto This website is the well known I liked it so much
AAA Toronto Payday Loans 1172 Bay St #101, Toronto, ON M5S 2B4 (416) 477-2817

Kyle said...

I never have come across a site such as the one you have here with so much refreshing interests. The remarks are very interesting.
E Cigarettes Tuscaloosa

Anonymous said...

I like how you took this subject and put a spin on it. Looks like your visitors thought the same thing.
How To Fight Fatigue And Sluggishness Naturally

Anonymous said...

very nice. I found the whole thing to be easy and fun to read. Not one boring part in it.
Happy Kids Personalized Gifts Reviews

Anonymous said...

It's always refreshing to see an issue like this take a different approach. I like how you wrote this article up. Very nice indeed.
Starcraft 2 Terran Build Order

Anonymous said...

I would love to see more things like this being published. It seems like it gets harder and harder to come across subjects like this one here.
Bulb America Reviews

Anonymous said...

I never realized this stuff was so popular. Some of the remarks people are leaving here are really interesting to read. I'll have to look more into this as it is rather intriguing.
Gearcor Reviews

Anonymous said...

Not a part about this i didn't like. looks like some others had different opinions though.
Ros-Hommerson Review

Anonymous said...

interesting topic. I like this sort of stuff.
Aloe Elite Reviews

Anonymous said...

Just wanted to say how much I really enjoy the content you provide. Especially the remarks you get from everybody who reads your stuff. Some of it is very interesting.
controlling menopause symptoms

Anonymous said...

Can't tell you how much I like this article. Great work.
Home Gallery Stores Reviews

Anonymous said...

I really liked this post. Good job to the person that wrote this.
Brave Soldier Reviews

Anonymous said...

I don't think I understand this too much. Guess i should read it again and try to find out.
Life Lock Reviews

Anonymous said...

This is really a different take on this matter. Who would have ever thought the responses your getting.
LogiPen Digital Reviews

disclaimer

Red And Black Hockey is not affiliated with or endorsed by the Carolina Hurricanes Hockey Club, the National Hockey League or any of its other member clubs. The opinions expressed herein are entirely those of RBH. Any comments made are the opinion of the commenter, and not necessarily that of RBH.
Whenever possible, RBH uses its own photography. Any incidental use of copyrighted material including photography, logos or other brand markings will not interfere with the owner's profits.